In the ever-dramatic world of NHL trades, few deals have sparked as much intrigue and heated debate as the recent exchange between the Montreal Canadiens and the St. Louis Blues. While most fans and analysts initially believed the Canadiens had missed out on a star and simply settled for a promising young player, new revelations are turning that narrative on its head.

Behind the scenes, the decision-making process may have been far more calculated—and controversial—than anyone realized.

Insider voices, including respected former scout Grant McCagg, are now suggesting that Montreal’s front office might have had their sights set on Zachary Bolduc all along, even when the more established Jordan Kyrou was seemingly on the table. If true, this twist could completely reshape how both fanbases and league insiders view the blockbuster trade.

With both players offering different strengths—Bolduc’s physicality and upside versus Kyrou’s proven scoring touch—the debate over who truly “won” the trade is only just beginning. As more details emerge, one thing is clear: this deal could have long-lasting implications for both franchises, and the full story is far from over.

Former scout Grant McCagg, who is still very plugged in around the NHL, just made a bold statement regarding the trade between the Canadiens and the Blues.

Let’s not forget that on July 1st, Montreal and St. Louis completed a trade involving young players Zachary Bolduc and Logan Mailloux.

Most observers assumed the Canadiens failed to acquire Jordan Kyrou and therefore “settled” for Zachary Bolduc in the deal.

But what if it was the other way around?

Grant McCagg is convinced the St. Louis Blues changed plans at the last minute and preferred keeping Zachary Bolduc over Jordan Kyrou

Wow! That would be huge.

“I have no doubt the Blues were more willing to give up Jordan Kyrou than Zachary Bolduc.”

That’s exactly what he said.

“What if it was the Canadiens who didn’t want Kyrou?”

– DLC

We recommend watching the full episode – it’s very interesting.

“People think the Habs took Zachary Bolduc after failing to land Kyrou, but it might be the opposite – Montreal may have specifically demanded Bolduc in return for Logan Mailloux.

It actually makes a lot of sense.”

– DLC

And when you think about it, it’s really not far-fetched.

Bolduc is more complete than Kyrou, more physical, better built for the NHL playoffs, and now it seems the Quebec native has potential in the faceoff circle too.

Two more interesting stats:

Bolduc recorded 14 points in 18 games to end the 2024-25 season, including 9 goals, and earns just $863,000 per year.

Kyrou posted 29 points in 40 games to close out the season, including 16 goals, but carries a hefty $8.125 million cap hit annually through 2031.

I’m really starting to wonder if the Canadiens didn’t end up better off with Zachary Bolduc compared to Jordan Kyrou – even though Kyrou is clearly a very talented hockey player.