It started as a whisper, a fleeting rumor quietly circulating among diehard hockey fans on a Monday morning. But within hours, the buzz had grown louder, swelling into a full-blown debate that has gripped the Montreal Canadiens universe and spilled over into the wider NHL community. At the heart of this swirling speculation is a name that resonates deeply with fans in Quebec and beyond: Samuel Montembeault. The possibility of the beloved goaltender being traded has ignited a firestorm of opinions, emotions, and, perhaps most intriguingly, wild trade scenarios that no one saw coming.

For many, Montembeault is more than just a player—he’s a symbol of local pride, a homegrown talent who has earned the respect and admiration of teammates and supporters alike. So when whispers of a potential move to the Edmonton Oilers began to surface, it was as if a sensitive nerve had been struck. The reactions have been swift, passionate, and at times, surprisingly divided. With every passing hour, new voices join the conversation, each bringing their own perspective and fueling the sense of uncertainty that now hangs over the Canadiens’ goaltending situation.

The drama reached new heights when the team at 100% Max on BPM Sports reignited the discussion, adding fuel to the fire with a provocative debate that quickly captured the attention of fans and insiders. The conversation, led by Max Lalonde and Olivier Paiement, took a turn that few could have predicted. Drawing on insights from respected hockey journalist David Pagnotta, Lalonde speculated that Jakub Dobes’ impressive start to the season might have prompted the Canadiens to showcase Montembeault in hopes of attracting interest from teams like the Oilers. Yet, even as he floated the idea, Lalonde made it clear he was skeptical, pointing to Montembeault’s roots in Bécancour as a reason the Canadiens might hesitate to let him go.

But the discussion didn’t stop there. Olivier Paiement pushed back, suggesting that everything hinges on what Edmonton might be willing to offer in return. The mere mention of a star player like Ryan Nugent-Hopkins sent shockwaves through the fanbase, raising the stakes and opening the door to a host of tantalizing possibilities. Would the Oilers part with a proven scorer in exchange for a goaltender who has yet to fully establish himself as a number-one option? Is there a scenario where both teams walk away winners, or is the risk simply too great?

As the debate rages on, one thing is clear: the situation is fluid, unpredictable, and loaded with potential. With Dobes continuing to impress and the Oilers rumored to be searching for a reliable netminder, the landscape could shift in an instant. And while no one knows exactly where this story will lead, the sense of anticipation is palpable. Will the Canadiens make a move that shocks the league? Or will they hold firm, betting on their homegrown talent to carry them through the season?

One thing is certain—this is a story that demands your attention. The stakes are high, the emotions are raw, and the outcome could reshape the future for both franchises. Are you ready to find out what happens next?

Canadiens goalie Samuel Montembeault and Edmonton Oilers logo

Photo credit: All Habs / NHL

Since Monday morning, the rumors surrounding a Samuel Montembeault trade have been generating a lot of buzz.

Now the guys from 100% max on BPM sports reignited everything with a discussion that raises a very specific possible return, even though no one knows yet where this could lead.

The famous topic everyone has been talking about since Monday morning…

Samuel Montembeault potentially being traded to the Edmonton Oilers.

Each sentence is short because the reactions are coming fast.

And this topic hits a sensitive nerve among fans.

Especially because he’s a very well-liked Quebec-born goaltender.

The debate between Max Lalonde and Olivier Paiement restarts the rumours

On BMP Sports, Max Lalonde explained that, according to David Pagnotta, Jakub Dobes’ strong start to the season may have pushed the Canadiens to give more starts to Samuel Montembeault to “put him in the shop window,” since teams like the Oilers could be interested.

Max added that he doesn’t really believe it.

“Me, I don’t think the Canadiens could trade Sam Montembeault for the simple and only reason that his name is Sam Montembeault and he’s from Bécancour.”

– Max Lalonde

Olivier Paiement replied that everything depends on what the Oilers would have to offer.

And that they obviously will not give up a player like Ryan Nugent-Hopkins for no reason.

Max reminded everyone that Nugent-Hopkins is 32 years old with 276 career goals, but he still asked: is that really what you want?

Then Olivier dropped a trade proposal that instantly made everyone react:

“Ryan Nugent-Hopkins for Montembeault, I would do it! But I don’t think the Oilers would be willing to offer that.”

– Olivier Paiement

A simple statement, but one that completely changes the tone of the conversation.

In the end, the question remains open.

And honestly, I think this situation will continue to grow if Dobes keeps playing well and if Edmonton starts looking for a real number-one goaltender, because things can move quickly in this league.