The mood in Montreal is tense, and the pressure on the Canadiens has rarely felt heavier than it does right now. With injuries piling up and the team struggling to find its rhythm, every decision made by the coaching staff is under intense scrutiny. But nothing has sparked more heated debate—and outright controversy—than the recent call-up of forward Joshua Roy. In a season already marked by uncertainty and frustration, this move has set off a firestorm of reactions from fans and analysts alike, leaving many to wonder what is really happening behind the scenes at the Bell Centre.

Joshua Roy’s journey to the NHL is, on paper, a story of hard work and promise. After a strong start with the Laval Rocket, where he tallied seven points and boasted a +4 rating in just ten games, his recall to the Canadiens roster seemed to be a reward for his early-season performance. Yet, the transition hasn’t been seamless. The impressive numbers from the AHL have not translated into immediate impact at the NHL level, and the critics have been quick to pounce.

Social media has become a battleground, with passionate voices on both sides of the debate. Some fans are baffled by the decision, questioning whether Roy truly deserves a spot on the roster right now. Others are openly frustrated, suggesting that the organization is repeating past mistakes by promoting a player who, in their eyes, has yet to prove himself against the league’s best. The criticism has been sharp and, at times, unforgiving. Quotes from fans and commentators alike have flooded the internet, painting a picture of a city divided over the future of one of its young prospects.

But what’s really driving this reaction? Is it simply the pressure of a tough season, or is there something deeper at play? The Canadiens’ recent struggles have magnified every lineup change, and Joshua Roy’s call-up has become a symbol of the uncertainty surrounding the team. Some see it as a desperate move, a gamble made in hopes of finding a spark amid a growing injury list and lackluster results. Others view it as a sign of faith in youth, a willingness to give a promising player a chance to prove himself on the biggest stage.

Behind the scenes, the coaching staff faces difficult choices. Martin St-Louis, tasked with guiding the team through turbulent waters, knows that every decision will be dissected and debated. The call-up of Roy is just the latest flashpoint, but it has quickly become one of the most talked-about moments of the season. Fans are watching closely, searching for answers and hoping for signs of improvement.

As the drama unfolds, one thing is clear: Joshua Roy’s presence on the Canadiens roster has become a lightning rod for controversy. The stakes are high, and the outcome is far from certain. Will Roy rise to the occasion and silence his critics, or will this experiment become another chapter in a season full of questions? The answers remain hidden for now—but one thing is for sure: you won’t want to miss what happens next.

Photo of Canadiens forward Joshua Roy

Photo credit: NHL

The Canadiens are battling injuries and a rough start, and the call-up of Joshua Roy is creating strong reactions among fans and sparking plenty of debate.

Joshua Roy was recalled this Sunday after a good start to the season with the Laval Rocket. In ten games, he registered seven points and posted a +4 rating.

However, we have to admit that this isn’t really translating to the NHL.

Despite these very promising numbers, criticism is taking over. Several observers claim he does not deserve this call-up.

The criticism surrounding Joshua Roy and his NHL status is exploding

On social media, many did not hold back.

One message said:

“Roy isn’t an NHL player at all. Don’t know what he did to deserve that call up either”

– Michael

Another added:

“Not sure why they keep trying with Roy, he’s not an NHL caliber player.”

– Mitchy Gallo

These comments sum up the situation well, and it’s not the first time this has happened.

Finally, here is another example of what could be read online:

“Why bring up Joshua Roy? We know what he brings “nothing”! I’d much rather see Xhekaj (Florian) called up.

It’s always Roy and he’s never noticeable! The only time I’ve noticed so far was when Columbus scored and he didn’t have his man covered!”

– HabsFan67

In short, you get the hint.

Joshua Roy’s call-up has become a flashpoint in a season already filled with uncertainty for the Canadiens, and every lineup decision for St-Louis is under the microscope right now.