The Toronto Maple Leafs’ latest victory over the Nashville Predators should have been a cause for celebration, especially after a high-scoring display that electrified fans and showcased the team’s offensive depth. Yet, beneath the excitement of a 7-4 win, a simmering debate has emerged surrounding the leadership style of captain Auston Matthews. In the aftermath of a controversial incident involving rookie Easton Cowan, some fans are questioning whether Matthews is doing enough to protect his teammates—sparking heated discussions across social media and in hockey circles alike.

Matthews, known for his elite scoring touch and pivotal role on the ice, found himself at the center of attention for reasons beyond his two-goal performance. When Cowan was sent crashing into the goal post, many expected their captain to leap into action, but Matthews chose a different path—one that has left many wondering about his priorities and the true nature of leadership in today’s NHL.

Is Matthews’ approach a sign of maturity and strategic thinking, or does it expose a troubling lack of grit? As the season unfolds, his decisions could have far-reaching consequences not just for his own health, but for the Maple Leafs’ fortunes. The real story behind Matthews’ restraint may surprise you—read on to find out more.

Toronto Maple Leafs forward Auston Matthews firing a shot on goal against the Nashville Predators.

Photo credit: Dan Hamilton – Imagn Images

Leafs captain Auston Matthews finds himself in hot water with a portion of the fanbase that believes he needs to get into scrums to protect his teammates.

The Toronto Maple Leafs secured a 7-4 victory over the Nashville Predators last night, but fans are buzzing about captain Auston Matthews’ reluctance to stick up for his teammates after some questionable hits.

In last night’s contest, Easton Cowan was forcefully pushed into his own goal post. Many were surprised when his captain, Auston Matthews, didn’t jump into the scrum to stick up for his rookie.

Why it Makes Sense For Auston Matthews to Stay Clear of Scrums

Given Matthews’ injury history, primarily with his wrists, it was a strategy that made sense. Injury-aside, the Leafs were also gearing up for a power play, and having Matthews risking a roughing penalty that could send him to the box would not have been a smart decision.

Additionally, the Leafs’ bread and butter right now is their depth, which means other players, like Max Domi, Dakota Joshua, Nicolas Roy, Jake McCabe, and Chris Tanev – who actually retaliated against Wiesblatt for the hit – can handle the grittier and more physical workload.

Auston Matthews’ True Value to the Team

While it’s understandable why it can be rage inducing when you see one of your star players seemingly skating away from the rough stuff, Matthews has a legitimate gripe since the Leafs desperately need him to be healthy and scoring.

At this stage of the season, Matthews’ cautious approach isn’t just about avoiding penalties, it’s about staying healthy. He missed 15 games last season, a chunk of contests in both 2021-22 and 2022-23, and several crucial playoff games in 2024 due to upper body injuries.

Moreover, Matthews reminded everyone of his value last night with his two-goal performance, which included the eventual game-winner midway through the third period. Showcasing he’s better suited on the ice than in the penalty box – or even the press box tending to an injury.

The season is still young and Matthews looks healthier right now than we’ve seen in recent years. There will be plenty of opportunities down the road for him to get into skirmishes, but right now is not the time.

Keeping Matthews on the ice and out the penalty box might be the Leafs’ best strategy this season for winning games and keeping him as healthy as possible.