A seismic shift has just rocked the world of hockey in Pittsburgh, sending fans and analysts alike scrambling for answers. The iconic rivalry between two legendary names—Sidney Crosby and Mario Lemieux—has reached a new and unexpected chapter, sparking debates and excitement across the NHL community. For years, the question of who truly stands atop the Pittsburgh Penguins’ storied history has divided loyal supporters and fueled endless conversations in rinks, bars, and living rooms.

Now, with another milestone quietly slipping into the record books, the conversation is heating up once again. What does this new achievement mean for Crosby’s legacy? Is it finally time to reconsider the long-held belief that Lemieux is the franchise’s greatest? Or do the circumstances surrounding these two superstars add even more complexity to an already fascinating story?

As whispers of a remarkable accomplishment begin to circulate, one thing is certain: the battle for the Penguins’ crown has never been more compelling. With both Crosby and Lemieux boasting a treasure trove of accolades and unforgettable moments, fans are left wondering what truly sets them apart—and what recent events might finally tip the scales. The answer may surprise you, and it’s a story you won’t want to miss.

Sidney Crosby of the Pittsburgh Penguins.

Photo credit: The Hockey Writers

Sidney Crosby is one of the greatest players in NHL history, and now he’s passed the iconic Mario Lemieux for an incredible Pittsburgh Penguins record.

For years now, Sidney Crosby has continued growing his legacy with the Pittsburgh Penguins, and with three Stanley Cups under his belt, he’s arguably the greatest player in franchise history already.

That’s a steep mountain to climb however, as ‘Super Mario’ Lemieux is regarded as the Penguins current greatest, but as of late, Crosby has been racking up records that puts himself alongside No. 66 among the best in franchise history.

Crosby passes Lemieux for major Penguins record

Last season, Crosby passed Wayne Gretzky for the most point-per-game seasons in the history of the National Hockey League, tallying his 20th in 2024/25 despite the struggles from the team overall, and now, he’s passed fellow Penguins icon Lemieux for another.

According to the Penguins official release on social media, Crosby now has the most combined points between the regular season and Stanley Cup Playoffs in franchise history (1,896), passing Lemieux (1,895) in the process.

Clearly, post-season success and longevity play a major role in Crosby getting to this record, with many seeing Lemieux’s health issues that kept him out of the NHL for several years as holding him back from being considered the greatest player in league history.

Ultimately, both Lemieux and Crosby are considered icons in the history of the Penguins franchise, bringing multiple Stanley Cups and years of success to the organization, but with Crosby now producing more total points in franchise history than Lemieux, it may be time for fans to start taking the arguments about the two seriously.